Thunar 1.8.13 Is Released With Unfortunate Bug That Makes It Useless As A File Manager

From LinuxReviews
Jump to navigationJump to search
Xfce4-whiskermenu.svg

The latest release of the Thunar file manager for the Xfce desktop environment has several bug fixes, including crash fixes, and a new bug which breaks drag and drop of multiple files. Select 4 or 10 files in Thunar 1.8.13 and drag them and only one of the files is dragged along thanks to a very unfortunate commit for opening multiple files in a single application. It is very unfortunate that the commit which added that feature made Thunar utterly useless as a file manager and it is quite embarrassing that the Xfce team released Thunar with such a usability-breaking bug.

written by 윤채경 (Yoon Chae-kyung). published 2020-03-25last edited 2020-03-25

Thunar-1.8.13-git.jpg
Thunar 1.8.13 git with two very unfortunate commits reverted.

The Xfce teams "Release notes" story for Thunar 1.8.13 is:

  • Use tre-view toplevel path of the cursor, if available, in order to prevent jumping (Bug #16024)
  • Increase vertical gap between icon and its label slightly (Bug #16041)
  • Fix crash when inserting USB device in tree-view mode. (Bug #15172)
  • Fix jump to Home when ejecting a currently viewed device (Bug #16504)
  • Allow context menu when editing location in pathbar (Bug #16483)
  • Sort device entries in tree view (Bug #16471)
  • Allow to open multiple files at once (Bug #2487)
  • Fix incorrect pathbar autocomplete (Bug #16267)
  • Avoid unreadable names in detailed view (Bug #16391)
  • Prevent crash when renaming files (Bug #10805)
  • Translation Updates: Belarusian, Croatian, Finnish, French, Hebrew, Indonesian, Kazakh, Malay, Portuguese, Portuguese (Brazil),

The official release note story neglects to mention that the "Allow to open multiple files at once" commit breaks drag and drop of multiple files. That total scandal makes Thunar utterly useless for file management. Using Dolphin, Nemo, Caja, GNU Midnight Commander and everything and anything else, even GNOME's joke of a file manager "Files", is preferable to trying to manage multiple files with Thunar 1.8.13 due to that gigantic blunder.

"It can be seen as a bug when you select multiple files and open them, and only the last one is opened. That's why I pushed it as well to 4.14 ... wonder why I did not notice that flaw since now, I am working with that fix since a month now. I should do some more DnD from time to time."

anonymous Xfce developer source
who pushed the commit

"I didn't do any dragging of multiple file either"

another anonymous Xfce developer source

"Sorry for my bad patch everyone. I clearly didn't test it enough."

anonymous Xfce developer source
who wrote the committed patch

Those who use the git version of Thunar can revert the offending commit 9801a67b3a165fc1be81b520ec28b5529a9ab822 as well as fe53f759991f3e5df89a4496dc9b353d0560b762 (which fixed a warning caused by the removeal of 9801a67b3a165fc1be81b520ec28b5529a9ab822, it will fail to compile if you don't revert this too) to get a sane and working Thunar with functional support for dragging and dropping multiple files.

The source code for Thunar 1.8.13 can be acquired from archive.xfce.org/src/xfce/thunar/1.8/. You should absolutely NOT download and compile it, you should avoid it at all cost. Use 1.8.12 or the version included in your distribution, which is probably fine, instead of upgrading until a 1.8.13.1 or a 1.8.14 release which fixes the drag and drop issue becomes available.

Kemonomimi rabbit.svg
Update: Thunar 1.8.14 Is Released. It has the commit which broke drag and drop reverted. It is otherwise identical to 1.8.13.



avatar

Anonymous user #1

4 months ago
Score 1++
Is this a serious news site, or just an immature blog of some author trying to boost his ego? Is this a real bug? If yes, then why didn't the author report it to Xfce Bugzilla? It would certainly take less time than writing such an awful news item, and it would certainly help more people.
avatar

Chaekyung

4 months ago
Score 0++

It is a real bug. I messaged the Thunar developers about five minutes before I wrote this article, they already know which commit to look at and they will likely have a working solution within a day or two.

As for this site, it's not a "serious news site", it is more like a hobby.
avatar

Anonymous user #1

4 months ago
Score 0++
maybe he caught corona
avatar

Anonymous user #1

4 months ago
Score 0++
Which font are you using?
avatar

Chaekyung

4 months ago
Score 0++

I am using Noto Sans Regular 11 as the default font and DejaVu Sans Mono Regular 11 as Monospace font at a 162 DPI setting with RGB sub-pixel rendering and full hinting.

Xfce4-appearence-settings-git.jpg
Add your comment
LinuxReviews welcomes all comments. If you do not want to be anonymous, register or log in. It is free.