Cantata 2.4.0 Is Released

From LinuxReviews
Jump to navigationJump to search
Media-optical-audio.png

It has been a year since the last version of the best Music Player Daemon front-end built on the Qt and KDE libraries was released. The latest version has some new features but it also lacks a rather important one previous versions have: Support for showing the currently playing songs album cover in the playlist window has been taken away due to issues with that feature when Cantata is build against Qt 5.12. That huge disappointment can safely be fixed by changing the cmake configuration file if you compile against newer Qt versions.

written by 윤채경 (Yoon Chae-kyung). published 2020-12-16last edited 2020-02-16

WJSN Bona disappointed cropped.jpg
The new Cantata release is so disappointing it probably makes WJSNs Bona sad (even if she is unaware of its existence)

Downloading, compiling and starting the newly released Cantata 2.4.0 was a huge disappointment. The release notes for Cantata 2.4.0 mention that "Custom playqueue background is not working with Qt 5.12 onwards, so disabled for now". That change is immediately visible and very apparent. This is what Cantata 2.4.0 looks like:

Cantata-2.4.0-playlist.jpg
Cantata 2.4.0 with a plain white playlist background.

A close-up inspection of the above screenshot of Cantata 2.4.0 versus the following screenshot of Cantata 2.3.1, released in June 2018, should reveal a somewhat important difference:

Cantata-2.3.1-playlist.jpg
Cantata 2.3.1 (and 2.3.3) will show you the currently playing songs album cover in the playlist background. The latest version does not have that feature.

A keen observer will notice that version 2.3.1 will show album covers in the playlist background if that feature is enabled in Edit ▸ Preferences ▸ Interface ▸ Play Queue where version up to 2.3.3 has a "Background Image" setting where it is possible to choose either no background image, "Current album cover" or a "Custom image". Cantata 2.4.0 has no such option:

{Cantata-settings-2.3.3-vs-2.4.0.jpg
Cantata 2.4.0 lacks any option to configure the playlist background.

The removal of the support for showing album covers in the playlist background is so hugely disappointing that it is barely worth mentioning that Cantata 2.4.0 can show invalid (removed) files present in playlists using red text and that there is a new Remove Invalid Tracks option in the playlists context menu.

It is also barely worth mentioning that those who enjoy podcasts can enjoy a new feature for reading local RSS and OPML files in the podcast search dialog. These new features do in no way make up for the removal of the currently played songs album cover in the playlist.

Why Would He Do This?

The obvious question is WHY, why would Cantata developer Craig Drummond remove the ability to have album covers in the playlists background? A close-up inspection of the git changelog reveals a large change-set titled "Custom playqueue background is not workig with Qt 5.12 onwards, so disabled for now - which refers to issue #1554. Luckily, a comment on that issue does mention that:

"Just in case anyone wants to look into this, to re-enable this feature edit config.h.cmake and change
#define ENABLE_VIEW_BACKGROUND (QT_VERSION < QT_VERSION_CHECK(5, 12, 0))
to
#define ENABLE_VIEW_BACKGROUND 1"

Craig Drummond on Cantata issue #1554
December 4th, 2019

Setting #define ENABLE_VIEW_BACKGROUND 1 in config.h.cmake and recompiling does restore the previous behavior - and it works just fine with Qt 5.13.2. The problems described in #1554 with Cantata built against Qt 5.12 are not there with Qt 5.13.2.

The Cantata 2.4.0 release notes mention that there are two crash fixes as well as several minor bug-fixes in this release. There is also a new --fullscreen option for starting it in fullscreen. Artist images are now pulled from FanArt.tv instead of Last.fm due to changes on Last.fm's side.

Do note that Cantata is a front-end for the Music Player Daemon, it is not a stand-alone music player like Elisa. You need to have mpd installed and running to use it.

The source code for Cantata 2.4.0 can be acquired from the GitHub release page. You may want to change config.h.cmake before you compile it - unless your system is using Qt 5.12.

Kemonomimi rabbit.svg
Update: Cantata developer Craig Drummond will "re-enable this (playlig background images) option for 2.4.1" and "try to release 2.4.1 in about a week - just to give time for an extra issues."
0.00
(0 votes)


avatar

Anonymous user #1

5 months ago
Score 1++
I've updated Cantata for 2.4.1 to re-enable this background for Qt>=5.13.2 - 2.4.1 should be released in about a week.
avatar

Anonymous user #2

one month ago
Score 0++

Fantastic! Cantata is my favourite music player -especially because of the art display, for both background AND artist view so t is good to read that FanArt.tv replaces Last.fm! I was really not expecing a new release especially after the notification 'Cantata is now in a bug-fix only state.' I mostly use Cpod for podcasts but the new function should be great also! I have previously donated to the Cantata project but it appears Craig is not overly keen to develop though. If that is the case it would be fantastic for KDE to bring it under their umbrella! To be clear - I am on Kubuntu QT 5.12.8, so should I wait for QT13 before installing/upgrading to v4.2.1?

Thanks!
Add your comment
LinuxReviews welcomes all comments. If you do not want to be anonymous, register or log in. It is free.