Fediverse

From LinuxReviews
Jump to navigationJump to search
Fediverse logo proposal.png

Fediverse is a loose term for a network of social network servers which form an alternative to centralized social network platforms like Twitter. Fediverse servers use the open ActivityPub standard to share content users on individual servers between the servers in the network. A variety of software such as Mastodon and Pleroma can be used to run Fediverse servers. Individual servers have widely different communities, policies and features. Some have draconian censorship-policies and others have a clear pro free speech stance.

The Fediverse Network

A proposed Fediverse logo illustrating how individual servers are supposed to form a global social network. This is, in reality, not how it works.

The "Fediverse" is a network of social media style services who are, in theory, capable to interacting with each other. Services using the Mastodon social media software have a "Federeated" timeline as one of their core features. That timeline shows all posts from all the servers that Mastodon instance is interacting with which is typically not all the servers in the fediverse network. The front page of servers running Mastodon will, as a default, falsely advertise:

"With an account on $servername you'll be able to follow people on any Mastodon server and beyond."

default Mastodon software message

A scarily large majority of the fediverse servers do not only censor local users, they also censor entire servers for reasons that are, in many cases, quite strange. A server which has blacklisted another server will not just omit the posts from the blacklisted server in the Federeated timeline, a blacklist entry will also prevent users from following users on the blacklisted server. That is kind of silly from a practical perspective. A user on a server which has blacklisted another server can go to that servers web page and see all the posts but can't subscribe to the users there even though all the data is publicly available.

How many servers a fediverse instance is blocking and why those servers are blocked is in most cases not clearly stated anywhere. It is therefore hard to know if people using other servers will be able to follow you and see posts you make on the server you are using.

Public Fediverse Servers

url policy software focus primary language open for signups
elekk.xyz heavily censored Mastodon Socialism English No
fedi.z0ne.moe uncensored Pleroma friendly server with focus on drawing(s) English Yes
freespeechextremist.com uncensored Pleroma Extreme Free Speech English Yes
gab.com uncensored Own Mastodon fork Anime, technology, free speech English Yes
juche.town uncensored Pleroma some kind of town English Yes
jpop.club Pleroma Japanese pop music English / Japanese no Yes!!
kawen.space unknown Pleroma The Pillow Fort of Pleroma Instances. Very pink. Looks comfy. English Yes
liberdon.com uncensored Mastodon For libertarians, ancaps, anarchists, etc English Yes
mastodon.cloud Mastodon heavily censored[1] Mostly bots re-posting from rags like the New York Times English Yes
mastodon.social heavily censored[1] Mastodon 白左 báizuǒ discussing how everything is offensive English Invite only
mastodon.xyz somewhat censored Mastodon General talk English No
mstdn.io uncensored[2] Mastodon General talk. Many tech related posts. Comfortable. English Yes
pawoo.net uncensored Mastodon general talk Japanese Yes
pl.smuglo.li uncensored Pleroma Smug content. NOT work safe English Yes
snabelen.no heavily censored Mastodon Norwegian language content. Mostly harmless posts about farming[3] Norweigan Yes
todon.nl heavily censored[4] Mastodon 聖母婊 hangout English Yes
theres.life unknown Mastodon God and Jesus Christ English Yes
wxw.moe uncensored Mastodon moe English Yes

The "censored" servers are censoring more than posts on their own platform, they are also censoring everything posted on other servers in in realty not very interconnected "fediverse". Some, like todon.nl, have administrators who go out of their way to dox and research people's private life and ban people for having some post in some old blog or something.

The above list is in no way complete. fediverse.network has a much larger list of fediverse servers which includes the server software used, the number of users and the number of peers the servers are federating with.

Mobile applications

Fedilab

Fedilab is a good choice if you are looking for a Android application to use with fediverse servers running Mastodon or Pleroma.

Fedilab does cost money in the Google Play store. It is available for free in the free software F-Droid app-store: https://f-droid.org/en/packages/fr.gouv.etalab.mastodon/

Tootdon

The developers of the mobile software Tootdon decided to shut it down in July 2019 when they realized that a large amount of users were using this application to by-pass the built-in censorship in other mobile Masterdon client applications.

Tusky

The mobile phone application Tusky for accessing the Mastodon network has censorship built into the application. Some ActivityPub-compatible instances can simply not be used by the Tusky mobile application due to it's built-in blacklist.

Tusky-source.jpg

Tusky's "Community Manger" Marie Axelsson claimed that "This is not censorship, but rather a choice by this house who will facilitate our service to" in a commit June 2019.

Tusky-not-censorship.jpg

A built-in blacklist is of course censorship. Someone trying to decide what you can and can't see and read for you is the very definition of censorship. It is also worth considering if an app is the service it's users are interested in or if it's like a web browser used to access services on the Internet. Other comparisons to web browsers are worth thinking about: There are currently no web browsers who will go "you can't have that domain because we don't like the opinions shared on that one". And that's a good thing.

notes

  1. 1.0 1.1 It is impossible to follow anyone on the vast majority of openPub compatible servers from this Mastodon instance. It is hard to say if they are censoring a really high number of other servers or if there is something plain broken with the software or the server they are using. Regardless, their promise of "you'll be able to follow people on any Mastodon server and beyond" is false; you will be able to follow people on that server and two or three others.
  2. The mstdn.io instances administrator appears to be constantly harassed because he does not want to censor gab.com
  3. https://snabelen.no/@Jordbruket
  4. todon.nl's censorship goes beyond their own website. the administrator actively researches users and ban them for writing things elsewhere


avatar

Anonymous user #1

7 months ago
Score 0++
those admins are sick people
avatar

Anonymous user #1

7 months ago
Score 0++
death to censorship !
avatar

Anonymous user #2

5 months ago
Score 0++
One thing that frustrates me to no end is that i can see the timeline of people in blocking instances, but cant see their tweets on my feed because the censoring instances will deny any follow requests. Why there are requests in the first place? Just follow them and be done. This is a great deal breaker for me, I dont want to type the profile's handle every time I want to see what they are up too. This breaks the idea of networking entirely
avatar

Anonymous user #2

4 months ago
Score 0++
"fediverse" already is a stupid-sounding word, small wonder it totally breaks left, right and centre...
Add your comment
LinuxReviews welcomes all comments. If you do not want to be anonymous, register or log in. It is free.